The Wax Jacket Dilemma: Barbour Beaufort vs. Bedale – Which Icon Is Your Perfect Match?

Choosing between the Barbour Beaufort and the Bedale involves understanding a few distinct functional details. While both jackets feature the signature waxed cotton construction, corduroy collars, and a comfortable, relaxed silhouette, they serve slightly different purposes. The Bedale is defined by its shorter length, whereas the Beaufort offers more torso coverage and a specialized rear storage compartment.

Quick Guide: Opt for the Bedale if you want a versatile, waist-length jacket for casual wear with denim or chinos. Select the Beaufort if you require a longer hem to hide a suit jacket or blazer, or if you need the extra utility of a rear pocket.

Below is a detailed breakdown of their histories, fit profiles, and specific features to help you identify the right investment for your wardrobe.

Key Distinctions Between the Barbour Beaufort and Bedale

This comparison focuses on the iconic, traditional versions of these waxed jackets. Keep in mind that modern collaborations or “slim fit” variants may deviate from these standard specifications.

Exploring the Heritage and Design of the Barbour Bedale

Introduced in 1980 by Dame Margaret Barbour, the Bedale was originally engineered as a performance riding jacket. Its shorter cut and dual rear vents were specifically designed to prevent the fabric from bunching while in a saddle.

Today, those same equestrian features translate perfectly to modern life. The shorter hem makes it exceptionally comfortable for driving or commuting, and the generous cut allows for heavy knitwear underneath. The Bedale includes the classic four-pocket arrangement: two large bellows pockets for storage and two moleskin-lined handwarmer pockets. A standout feature is the internal knitted storm cuffs, which create a snug seal around the wrist to block out wind.

From a style perspective, the Bedale is highly adaptable. It pairs naturally with straight-leg denim, rugged boots, and sweatshirts, making it the go-to choice for a relaxed, heritage-inspired look.

Advantages of the Bedale

• Optimized Length: The shorter proportions feel more like a standard jacket than a heavy coat.
• Seated Comfort: The combination of a shorter body and rear vents ensures the jacket doesn’t ride up when sitting.
• Weather Protection: Ribbed cuffs offer superior protection against cold drafts entering the sleeves.
• Versatile Styling: Effortlessly complements casual wardrobes including trainers and jeans.

Potential Drawbacks

• Reduced Coverage: The higher hem provides less protection against wind and rain for the lower body.
• Tailoring Conflict: Because it is short, suit jackets or blazers often peek out from underneath the hem.
• Height Considerations: Taller individuals may find the proportions slightly cropped; checking sleeve length is essential.
• Generous Volume: The traditional “classic” fit can feel quite baggy if you are used to contemporary slim-fit outerwear.

The Bedale is the right choice if: You want a practical, everyday jacket primarily for casual outfits and don’t plan on wearing it over formal tailoring.

The Barbour Beaufort: A Versatile Field Classic

The Beaufort arrived in 1983, shortly after the Bedale. Inspired by French shooting coats, it was designed with field sports in mind. The most notable addition is the “game pocket”—a large, lined compartment accessible via side zips at the rear of the jacket.

The Beaufort’s primary advantage is its length. It sits several inches lower than the Bedale, providing better weather protection and ensuring that most sports coats or blazers stay hidden beneath the wax cotton shell. Instead of knitted cuffs, the Beaufort features adjustable wind cuffs that can be tightened or loosened, which some find more comfortable when wearing a watch or French cuffs.

While it has deep roots in country pursuits, the Beaufort’s polished, longer silhouette makes it a favorite for city professionals who need a rugged outer layer that still looks appropriate over a suit.

Advantages of the Beaufort

• Enhanced Protection: The longer hem keeps more of your body dry and warm in inclement weather.
Suit Compatibility: It is specifically designed with enough length to cover tailored jackets.
• Extra Utility: The rear game pocket is a unique storage feature for everything from newspapers to dog leads.
• Customizable Cuffs: The adjustable sleeve openings offer flexibility for different wrist sizes and layers.

Potential Drawbacks

• Extra Bulk: The additional length can feel slightly more cumbersome when navigating public transport or cars.
• Petite Fit Issues: Shorter individuals might find the Beaufort’s length overwhelming, making it look more like a coat than a jacket.
• Niche Features: Many urban wearers find they rarely utilize the specialized rear pocket.
• Traditional Cut: Like the Bedale, the roomy shape may feel too large for those preferring a tapered aesthetic.

The Beaufort is the right choice if: You need a jacket that bridges the gap between casual and formal, or if you simply prefer the extra coverage of a longer coat.

Deciphering Barbour Fabrics: Classic vs. Standard

When shopping for either model, you will likely encounter “Classic” and “Standard” (often just labeled by the model name) versions. This distinction refers to the type of wax cotton used rather than the fit of the jacket.

The standard versions typically utilize a 6oz Thornproof wax. This has a smooth, slightly glossy finish that develops a unique patina over time. The “Classic” versions utilize 6oz Sylkoil. Sylkoil is the oldest Barbour finish; it is “unshorn” and has a softer, more matte appearance right out of the box.

Both fabrics offer similar levels of durability and water resistance. Your choice should depend on whether you prefer a rugged, matte look (Classic/Sylkoil) or a slightly more polished, traditional sheen (Standard/Thornproof).

Mastering the Barbour Fit

Both the Bedale and the Beaufort are designed with a “Relaxed Fit.” This is intentional, as these jackets were built to accommodate thick wool sweaters or zip-in liners. When trying one on, look for ease of movement rather than a skin-tight look.

• Test Your Layers: Always try the jacket on with the thickest item you plan to wear underneath.
• Check the Range of Motion: Reach forward and upward to ensure the shoulders don’t bind and the sleeves don’t pull back too far.
• Closure Test: Fasten the jacket completely to ensure there is no tension across the hips or chest.
• The Sizing Trap: While some people size down for a slimmer look, be careful not to compromise sleeve length or the ability to layer, which can ruin the jacket’s utility.

Common Questions Regarding the Beaufort and Bedale

What is the most significant difference between the two?

Length and pockets are the deciding factors. The Beaufort is longer with a rear game pocket; the Bedale is shorter with rear riding vents and internal knitted cuffs.

Which jacket is warmer?

In terms of insulation, they are nearly identical as they use the same weight of waxed cotton and cotton lining. However, the Beaufort provides slightly more warmth simply by covering more of the body. Both jackets can be upgraded with Barbour’s zip-in liners for winter weather.

Are these jackets fully waterproof?

Waxed cotton is highly water-resistant and will keep you dry in most rain showers. However, it is not a “waterproof” technical garment in the same way a Gore-Tex shell is. Regular rewaxing is required to maintain its ability to shed water.

Can women wear these styles?

Absolutely. While Barbour offers specific women’s models (like the Beadnell), many women prefer the authentic, boxier cut of the original Bedale or Beaufort. It is important to check the sleeve length and shoulder width, as these are sized for men’s proportions.

Do they come with hoods?

Traditional Bedale and Beaufort jackets do not come with hoods included. However, they feature studs under the corduroy collar designed to attach a matching waxed hood, which is usually sold as a separate accessory.

How should I clean my waxed jacket?

Never machine wash, dry clean, or use detergent on a waxed Barbour. This will permanently strip the wax and damage the fabric. Instead, use a sponge and cold water to wipe away dirt. To maintain the jacket, it should be rewaxed approximately once a year.

Is buying a used Barbour a good idea?

Waxed Barbour jackets are famous for their longevity. A second-hand jacket can be a great value, but inspect it for “dry” spots where the wax has worn away, holes in the sleeve creases, and any unpleasant odors. Most old jackets can be restored to like-new condition with a professional rewax and minor repairs.

Final Summary and Recommendation

The choice between these two icons depends on your lifestyle and height. For a versatile, everyday outer layer that feels light and mobile, the Barbour Bedale is our top recommendation. Its equestrian heritage makes it the perfect companion for casual weekend wear and city commuting.

However, if you frequently wear tailored clothing or prefer the traditional look of a longer field coat, the Barbour Beaufort is the superior option. Its ability to cover a blazer and its additional storage capacity make it a functional powerhouse for both the country and the office. Whichever you choose, both jackets represent a timeless piece of British heritage that, with proper care, will last for decades.